A Theory-Based Analysis of Null Causality between HRM Practices and Outcomes: Evidence from Four-Wave Longitudinal Data

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Theory-Based Analysis of Null Causality between HRM Practices and Outcomes

T2 - Evidence from Four-Wave Longitudinal Data

AU - Ogbonnaya, Chidiebere

AU - Daniels, Kevin

AU - Messersmith, Jake

AU - Rofcanin, Yasin

N1 - Publisher Copyright: © 2022 The Authors. Journal of Management Studies published by Society for the Advancement of Management Studies and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

PY - 2023/9

Y1 - 2023/9

N2 - The last three decades have seen a growing interest in understanding the influence of human resource management (HRM) practices on employee job satisfaction and organizational performance. While the results have been generally positive, most studies have utilized cross-sectional research designs, which limit causal inferences. Recently, several studies have used longitudinal data but have not consistently found significant causal links between HRM practices and outcomes after controlling for past outcomes. This points to a tension in the literature that merits further investigation. Drawing on general systems theory (GST), we explore this issue by proposing and testing a set of null causal relationships involving HRM practices, organizational performance (i.e., patient satisfaction), and job satisfaction. We show that average scores on HRM practices and outcomes remain relatively stable at the organizational level over time, such that any observed within-organization change is likely negligible or non-significant. Using four-wave longitudinal data (with two, four, and six-year time lags) from the public healthcare sector, we argue that the causal links between HRM practices and outcomes are indeed sensitive to the forces of dynamic equilibrium operating within a highly institutionalized context. We use GST to highlight the self-sustaining nature of HRM systems and discuss the ramifications of this stability for strategic HRM research and practice.

AB - The last three decades have seen a growing interest in understanding the influence of human resource management (HRM) practices on employee job satisfaction and organizational performance. While the results have been generally positive, most studies have utilized cross-sectional research designs, which limit causal inferences. Recently, several studies have used longitudinal data but have not consistently found significant causal links between HRM practices and outcomes after controlling for past outcomes. This points to a tension in the literature that merits further investigation. Drawing on general systems theory (GST), we explore this issue by proposing and testing a set of null causal relationships involving HRM practices, organizational performance (i.e., patient satisfaction), and job satisfaction. We show that average scores on HRM practices and outcomes remain relatively stable at the organizational level over time, such that any observed within-organization change is likely negligible or non-significant. Using four-wave longitudinal data (with two, four, and six-year time lags) from the public healthcare sector, we argue that the causal links between HRM practices and outcomes are indeed sensitive to the forces of dynamic equilibrium operating within a highly institutionalized context. We use GST to highlight the self-sustaining nature of HRM systems and discuss the ramifications of this stability for strategic HRM research and practice.

KW - HRM practices

KW - job satisfaction

KW - lag effects

KW - null causality

KW - organizational performance

KW - reverse causality

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85142199715&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/joms.12881

DO - 10.1111/joms.12881

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85142199715

SN - 0022-2380

JO - Journal of Management Studies

JF - Journal of Management Studies

ER -